Dual-Task Resistance Training Improves Strength and Reduces Pain More Than Resistance Exercise Alone in Elbow Fracture Rehabilitation: A Randomized Controlled Trial.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to compare the effects of dual-task resistance training versus traditional resistance training on strength, pain, range of motion, and functionality in patients rehabilitating from elbow fractures.
Results Summary
Dual-task resistance training improved strength and reduced pain more than traditional resistance training, and only the dual-task group showed improvements in kinesiophobia. Both groups enhanced strength, reduced pain, improved functionality, and increased range of motion after 12 weeks.
Population
Individuals undergoing rehabilitation for elbow fractures (N=32).
Effective Dosage
Not specified (12-week program, frequency not detailed).
Duration
12 weeks.
Interactions
None mentioned.
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
dual-task resistance training | increase | strength | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | improved strength more than resistance training alone | #1 |
dual-task resistance training | decrease | pain | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | reduced pain more than resistance training alone | #2 |
dual-task resistance training | decrease | kinesiophobia | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | improved in kinesiophobia | #3 |
dual-task resistance training | increase | elbow strength | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | showed a significant negative association between kinesiophobia and increased elbow strength | #4 |
traditional resistance training | increase | strength | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | enhance strength | #5 |
traditional resistance training | decrease | pain | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | reduce pain | #6 |
traditional resistance training | increase | functionality | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | improve functionality | #7 |
traditional resistance training | increase | ROM | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | increase ROM | #8 |
dual-task resistance training | increase | strength | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | enhance strength | #9 |
dual-task resistance training | decrease | pain | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | reduce pain | #10 |
dual-task resistance training | increase | functionality | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | improve functionality | #11 |
dual-task resistance training | increase | ROM | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | increase ROM | #12 |
dual-task resistance training | no change | disability | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | No significant differences were observed between the group for disability | #13 |
dual-task resistance training | no change | passive ROM | patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures | - | No significant differences were observed between the group for passive ROM | #14 |
OBJECTIVE: To examine the effects on strength, pain intensity, range of motion (ROM), and functionality of a 12-week dual-task resistance exercise program in patients undergoing rehabilitation from elbow fractures. DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial. SETTING: Rehabilitation hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Individuals undergoing elbow fracture rehabilitation (N=32). INTERVENTION: Randomization was performed sequentially using numbered envelopes containing assignments to either an intervention group (dual-task resistance training using a mathematical task with self-regulation, N=18) or a control group (traditional resistance training, N=14) for 12 weeks. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcomes were muscle strength for elbow flexors and extensors and pain assessed by the visual analog scale from 0 to 100 mm. The secondary outcomes were kinesiophobia assessed by the Tampa Scale-11 and disability using the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand questionnaire and passive ROM. RESULTS: Dual-task resistance training improved strength and reduced pain more than resistance training alone (P<.05), and only the dual-task group improved in kinesiophobia (P<.05). The linear regression showed a significant negative association between kinesiophobia and increased elbow strength in the dual-task group (flexion, r=-0.53, P=.024; extension, r=-0.65, P=.004) but not in the control group (P>.05). No significant differences were observed between the group for disability and passive ROM (P>.05). CONCLUSIONS: Dual-task resistance training and traditional resistance training both enhance strength, reduce pain, improve functionality, and increase ROM after 12 weeks of elbow fracture rehabilitation. However, dual-task resistance training is superior to resistance training alone in enhancing strength and reducing pain.