Vaping to quit smoking: Qualitative study of people receiving opioid agonist treatment.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to explore how individuals on opioid agonist treatment (OAT) experienced nicotine vaping as a smoking cessation tool.
Results Summary
Participants found vaping cheaper, more acceptable, and less stigmatizing than smoking but had concerns about accessibility. While vaping helped many quit smoking, some experienced cravings and withdrawal, suggesting a potential need for higher nicotine doses.
Population
Patients on opioid agonist treatment (OAT), including four Aboriginal participants (total n=12, median age 44).
Effective Dosage
Not specified
Duration
Not specified
Interactions
None mentioned
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
nicotine vaping | decrease | cost | patients on opioid agonist treatment (OAT) | - | reported as cheaper | #1 |
nicotine vaping | increase | acceptability | patients on opioid agonist treatment (OAT) | - | reported as more acceptable | #2 |
nicotine vaping | decrease | stigma | patients on opioid agonist treatment (OAT) | - | reported as less stigmatising | #3 |
nicotine vaping | decrease | accessibility | patients on opioid agonist treatment (OAT) | - | expressed concerns about ongoing accessibility | #4 |
nicotine vaping | increase | technical challenge | some participants | - | found it technically challenging at first | #5 |
nicotine vaping | no change | technical challenge | some participants | - | not more so than standard nicotine replacement therapies | #6 |
nicotine vaping | increase | craving and withdrawal | participants | - | gave accounts of craving and withdrawal experiences | #7 |
nicotine vaping | increase | vaping frequency and intensity | participants | - | compulsions to vape frequently and intensely | #8 |
nicotine vaping | increase | nicotine dosage | participants | - | potentially indicating need for higher nicotine dosage | #9 |
nicotine vaping | increase | smoking cessation | participants | - | generally reported that vaping helped them quit smoking | #10 |
nicotine vaping | no change | nicotine addiction | some participants | - | worried about swapping nicotine addictions | #11 |
nicotine vaping | decrease | risk | others | - | glad to be using a lower-risk alternative | #12 |
nicotine vaping | neutral | experiences | this group | - | reported varied experiences | #13 |
nicotine vaping | increase | smoking cessation | this group | - | mainly optimistic that it could help them and others quit smoking | #14 |
INTRODUCTION: Most patients receiving opioid agonist treatment (OAT) smoke tobacco. Approved cessation interventions are less effective in this group than the wider population. We investigated how people on OAT experience nicotine vaping to quit smoking. METHODS: Patients on OAT randomised to the vaping arm of a smoking cessation trial were invited to participate in structured interviews incorporating broad pre-determined themes. A qualitative descriptive approach employing template analysis was used. Four authors coded transcripts, discussed discrepancies, modified the template using both inductive and deductive approaches. Authors made explicit their starting orientations and independent authors sought disconfirmatory data in a subsequent round of analysis. RESULTS: Four women and eight men (median age 44 years) participated, including four who identified as Aboriginal. Participants reported vaping as cheaper, more acceptable and less stigmatising than smoking but expressed concerns about ongoing accessibility due to the Australian prescription access model. Some found it technically challenging at first, but not more so than standard nicotine replacement therapies. Participants gave accounts of craving and withdrawal experiences, including supplementary use of nicotine patches, and compulsions to vape frequently and intensely, potentially indicating need for higher nicotine dosage. Participants generally reported that vaping helped them quit smoking, though some worried about swapping nicotine addictions. Others were glad to be using a lower-risk alternative. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: This group reported varied experiences of nicotine vaping but were mainly optimistic that it could help them and others quit smoking. This was despite initial nicotine cravings and concerns about remaining addicted long-term.