Comparative Effects of Exercise Interventions and Mindfulness-Based Interventions for Cognitive Impairment and Quality of Life in Breast Cancer Survivors During or After Cancer Treatment: A Systematic Review and Bayesian Network Meta-analysis.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to compare the effectiveness of various exercise and mindfulness-based interventions in improving cognitive impairment.
Results Summary
Mindfulness-based interventions were found to be more effective than exercise interventions for alleviating cognitive impairment, with acceptance and commitment therapy, neurofeedback training, Qigong, and meditation showing the best effects on different cognitive domains.
Population
Individuals with cognitive impairment (specific demographics not detailed in the abstract).
Effective Dosage
Not specified
Duration
Not specified
Interactions
None mentioned
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
mindfulness-based stress reduction | no change | cognitive function | patients with cognitive impairment | no significant change | showed no significantly greater improvement | #1 |
all interventions except mindfulness-based stress reduction | increase | cognitive function | patients with cognitive impairment | significantly greater | showed significantly greater improvement | #2 |
physical activity | increase | executive function | patients with cognitive impairment | better | showed better effect | #3 |
Qigong | increase | executive function | patients with cognitive impairment | better | showed better effect | #4 |
compensatory cognitive training | increase | verbal memory | patients with cognitive impairment | more effective | were more effective | #5 |
neurofeedback training | increase | verbal memory | patients with cognitive impairment | more effective | were more effective | #6 |
Qigong | increase | verbal memory | patients with cognitive impairment | more effective | were more effective | #7 |
sham Qigong | increase | verbal memory | patients with cognitive impairment | more effective | were more effective | #8 |
acceptance and commitment therapy | increase | cognitive function | patients with cognitive impairment | best | had the best effects | #9 |
neurofeedback training | increase | quality of life | patients with cognitive impairment | best | had the best effects | #10 |
Qigong | increase | executive function | patients with cognitive impairment | best | had the best effects | #11 |
mediation | increase | processing speed | patients with cognitive impairment | best | had the best effects | #12 |
mindfulness-based interventions | decrease | cognitive impairment | patients with cognitive impairment | more effective | were found to be more effective | #13 |
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this network meta-analysis was to compare the improvement effects of various exercise interventions and mindfulness-based interventions to determine the best interventions for the improvement of cognitive impairment. DESIGN: Seven databases were searched to screen randomized controlled trials of exercise interventions and mindfulness-based interventions to improve cognitive impairment. The network meta-analysis was performed using Revman 5.3, R 4.2.1 and ADDIS 1.16.8 software. RESULTS: Thirty-four randomized controlled trials involving 14 interventions were included in the study. In terms of cognitive function, except for mindfulness-based stress reduction, all interventions showed significantly greater improvement in cognitive function compared with conventional therapy. Physical activity and Qigong showed better effect in improving executive function. In terms of improving verbal memory, compensatory cognitive training, neurofeedback training, Qigong, and sham Qigong were more effective than other interventions. On performing surface under the cumulative ranking curve analysis, acceptance and commitment therapy, neurofeedback training, Qigong, and mediation had the best effects on cognitive function, quality of life, executive function, and processing speed, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Mindfulness-based interventions were found to be more effective than exercise interventions for alleviating cognitive impairment. More robust randomized controlled trials focusing on acceptance and commitment therapy for cognitive impairment are required to support the current evidence.