The potential of biomarkers for diagnosing insomnia: Consensus statement of the WFSBP Task Force on Sleep Disorders.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to evaluate the diagnostic usefulness of melatonin rhythm deficiency as a potential biomarker for insomnia.
Results Summary
The study found that deficient melatonin rhythm was among the biological measurements potentially useful for diagnosing insomnia, though further replication and standardized methodology are needed.
Population
Insomniacs (specific demographic details not provided).
Effective Dosage
Not specified
Duration
Not specified
Interactions
None mentioned
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
psychometric instruments | no change | diagnosing insomnia | - | - | confirmed to be the gold standard | #1 |
polysomnography-derived cyclic alternating pattern | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | emerged as potentially useful diagnostic instruments | #2 |
actigraphy | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | emerged as potentially useful diagnostic instruments | #3 |
BDNF levels | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | emerged as potentially useful diagnostic instruments | #4 |
heart rate around sleep onset | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | emerged as potentially useful diagnostic instruments | #5 |
deficient melatonin rhythm | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | emerged as potentially useful diagnostic instruments | #6 |
certain neuroimaging patterns | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | emerged as potentially useful diagnostic instruments | #7 |
routine polysomnography | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value | #8 |
EEG spectral analysis | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value | #9 |
heart rate variability | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value | #10 |
skin conductance | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value | #11 |
thermoregulation | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value | #12 |
oxygen consumption | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value | #13 |
HPA axis | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value | #14 |
inflammation indices | no change | diagnosis of insomnia | - | - | not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value | #15 |
OBJECTIVES: Thus far, the diagnosis of insomnia is based on purely clinical criteria. Although a broad range of altered physiological parameters has been identified in insomniacs, the evidence to establish their diagnostic usefulness is very limited. Purpose of this WFSBP Task Force consensus paper is to systematically evaluate a series of biomarkers as potential diagnostic tools for insomnia. METHODS: A newly created grading system was used for assessing the validity of various measurements in establishing the diagnosis of insomnia; these measurements originated from relevant studies selected and reviewed by experts. RESULTS: The measurements with the highest diagnostic performance were those derived from psychometric instruments. Biological measurements which emerged as potentially useful diagnostic instruments were polysomnography-derived cyclic alternating pattern, actigraphy, and BDNF levels, followed by heart rate around sleep onset, deficient melatonin rhythm, and certain neuroimaging patterns (mainly for the activity of frontal and pre-frontal cortex, hippocampus and basal ganglia); yet, these findings need replication, as well as establishment of commonly accepted methodology and diagnostic cut-off points. Routine polysomnography, EEG spectral analysis, heart rate variability, skin conductance, thermoregulation, oxygen consumption, HPA axis, and inflammation indices were not shown to be of satisfactory diagnostic value. CONCLUSIONS: Apart from psychometric instruments which are confirmed to be the gold standard in diagnosing insomnia, six biomarkers emerge as being potentially useful for this purpose.