Panacea Index Logo

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Effects of low-carbohydrate vs low-fat diets on weight loss and metabolic risk factors in obese/overweight individuals with impaired glucose regulation: A randomized controlled trial.

Asia Pacific journal of clinical nutrition
January 1, 2022
Huilan Guo et al. (6 authors)
Journal ArticleRandomized Controlled TrialHuman StudyClinical
Study Details

Study Goal

The researchers aimed to compare the effects of a low-carbohydrate diet (LCD) versus a low-fat diet (LFD) on weight loss, glycemic control, and metabolic risk factors in individuals with impaired glucose regulation (IGR).

Results Summary

Both LCD and LFD achieved similar weight loss and improvements in fasting blood glucose, with no significant differences in triglyceride (TG) or liver function markers. However, the low-fat diet showed more favorable effects on total cholesterol (TC) levels.

Population

Obese/overweight adults (mean age 39.2 years, 72.5% women) with impaired glucose regulation (IGR).

Effective Dosage

LCD: 20%-25% energy from carbohydrates, 30%-45% energy from fat, 40%-45% energy from protein.

Duration

10 weeks

Interactions

None mentioned

Extracted Claims (17)
InterventionDirectionEndpointPopulationDosageImpactClaim #
low-carbohydrate diet
decrease
weight
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
5.80±0.6 kg
presented similar mean reduction in
#1
low-fat diet
decrease
weight
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
6.36±0.57 kg
presented similar mean reduction in
#2
heath education
decrease
weight
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
4.49±0.98 kg
presented similar mean reduction in
#3
low-carbohydrate diet
decrease
fasting blood glucose
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
0.73±0.13 mmol/L
presented similar mean reduction in
#4
low-fat diet
decrease
fasting blood glucose
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
0.84±0.17 mmol/L
presented similar mean reduction in
#5
heath education
decrease
fasting blood glucose
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
0.58±0.14 mmol/L
presented similar mean reduction in
#6
low-carbohydrate diet
no change
TG
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
no differences in the improvements of
#7
low-fat diet
no change
TG
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
no differences in the improvements of
#8
low-carbohydrate diet
no change
liver function markers
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
no differences in the improvements of
#9
low-fat diet
no change
liver function markers
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
no differences in the improvements of
#10
low-fat diet
decrease
TC level
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
exhibited more favorable effects on
#11
low-carbohydrate diet
decrease
weight loss
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
achieved similar
#12
low-fat diet
decrease
weight loss
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
achieved similar
#13
low-carbohydrate diet
decrease
fasting glucose
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
achieved similar
#14
low-fat diet
decrease
fasting glucose
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
achieved similar
#15
low-carbohydrate diet
decrease
insulin reduction
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
achieved similar
#16
low-fat diet
decrease
insulin reduction
obese/overweight adults with impaired glucose regulation
-
achieved similar
#17
Abstract

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to compare the effects of low-carbohydrate diet (LCD) versus low-fat diet (LFD) on weight loss, glycemic control and metabolic risk factors in individuals with impaired glucose regulation (IGR) after 10-week intervention. METHODS AND STUDY DESIGN: In this 10-week randomized controlled trial, 90 obese/overweight adults with IGR were randomly assigned to consume either low-carbohydrate diet (20%-25% energy from carbohydrates, 30%-45% energy from fat, 40%-45% en-ergy from protein), or low-fat diet (40%-55% energy from carbohydrates, 20%-30% energy from fat, 20%-30% energy from protein), or heath education (HE) group. The anthropometry and body composition were collected at baseline, week 4, week 8 and week 10. The glycemia and metabolic indicators were assessed at baseline and week 10. RESULTS: A total of 69 participants (mean±SE age: 39.2±1.0 years, 72.5% women) completed the intervention and were included in the final analysis. At week 10, all three groups presented similar mean reduction in weight (LCD: 5.80±0.6 kg; LFD: 6.36±0.57 kg; HE: 4.49±0.98 kg), and fasting blood glucose (LCD: 0.73±0.13 mmol/L; LFD: 0.84±0.17 mmol/L; HE: 0.58±0.14 mmol/L). Additionally, there were no differences in the improvements of TG and liver function markers between diets, the low-fat diet exhibited more favorable effects on TC level. CONCLUSIONS: Both diets achieved similar weight loss, fasting glucose, and insulin reduction in short-term, suggesting each diet pattern could be an effective strategy for the prediabetes management.

Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
AdultBlood GlucoseDiet, Carbohydrate-RestrictedDiet, Fat-RestrictedDietary CarbohydratesFemaleGlucoseHumansInsulinMaleObesityOverweightRisk FactorsWeight Loss
Study Links
Quality Scores
SafetyNot Assessed
Efficacy75/10
Quality80/10
Citation Metrics
Total Citations1
Citations/Year0.3
Relative Citation Ratio0.16
NIH Percentile7.7%
Research Impact Scores
APT Score0.05
Weight Score2.28
Normalized Score0.66
Related Supplements