Panacea Index Logo

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Pharmacological management of osteoporosis in nursing home residents: the Shelter study.

Maturitas
January 1, 2021
Alireza Malek Makan et al. (9 authors)
Comparative StudyJournal ArticleHuman Study
Study Details

Study Goal

The researchers aimed to assess the prevalence of pharmacological osteoporosis prevention (including vitamin D, calcium, and bisphosphonates) in nursing home residents and its association with patient characteristics such as falls, fractures, cognitive impairment, and dependence in walking.

Results Summary

The study found low usage of osteoporosis medications (OMs) among nursing home residents, with only 1.5% using all three classes (vitamin D, calcium, and bisphosphonates). Usage varied widely by country, and under-treatment was noted in residents with recent falls, fractures, or walking dependence, while possible over-treatment occurred in those with high mortality risk.

Population

Nursing home residents from eight countries (Czech Republic, England, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, and Israel).

Effective Dosage

Not specified

Duration

Not specified

Interactions

None mentioned

Extracted Claims (18)
InterventionDirectionEndpointPopulationDosageImpactClaim #
vitamin D
no change
osteoporosis prevention
nursing home residents
16.2%
used by
#1
calcium
no change
osteoporosis prevention
nursing home residents
10.4%
used by
#2
bisphosphonates
no change
osteoporosis prevention
nursing home residents
4.5%
used by
#3
vitamin D, calcium and bisphosphonates
no change
osteoporosis prevention
nursing home residents
1.5%
used by
#4
bisphosphonate
no change
osteoporosis prevention
residents with a recent fracture
9.5%
used by
#5
vitamin D, calcium and bisphosphonates
no change
osteoporosis prevention
residents with a recent fracture
2.7%
used by
#6
vitamin D
no change
osteoporosis prevention
patients with recent falls
20.8%
used by
#7
calcium
no change
osteoporosis prevention
patients with recent falls
15.3%
used by
#8
vitamin D
no change
osteoporosis prevention
residents with severe cognitive impairment
15.5%
used by
#9
calcium
no change
osteoporosis prevention
residents with severe cognitive impairment
9.3%
used by
#10
bisphosphonate
no change
osteoporosis prevention
bisphosphonate users
33.7%
used by
#11
calcium
no change
osteoporosis prevention
bisphosphonate users
25.8%
used by
#12
vitamin D
no change
osteoporosis prevention
bisphosphonate users
17.4%
used by
#13
any osteoporosis medication
no change
use
nursing home residents across countries
from 66.8% in Finland to 3.0% in Israel
varied widely
#14
pharmacological prevention
decrease
osteoporosis prevention
residents with recent falls, fractures and dependence in walking
-
substantial under-treatment
#15
bisphosphonate
decrease
vitamin D-calcium combination use
bisphosphonate users
-
only two-thirds also took
#16
preventive pharmacotherapy
increase
osteoporosis prevention
residents with high mortality risk
-
possible over-treatment
#17
pharmacological prevention
no change
osteoporosis prevention
residents between countries
-
differed substantially
#18
Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To prevent osteoporotic fractures in nursing home residents a combination of bisphosphonates, calcium and vitamin D is recommended. This study assessed the prevalence of pharmacological osteoporosis prevention in nursing home residents from eight countries, and assessed its association with patient characteristics. DESIGN: Cross-sectional analyses of the SHELTER study data. We assessed the overall prevalence of osteoporosis medication (OM) use (vitamin D, calcium and bisphosphonates) in residents stratified for falls and fractures over last 30 days, health instability with high mortality risk, cognitive impairment, and dependence in walking. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Nursing home residents in the Czech Republic, England, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands and Israel. RESULTS: Of 3832 eligible residents, vitamin D, calcium and bisphosphonates were used by 16.2%, 10.4%, and 4.5% respectively. All 3 classes of OM together were used by 1.5% of all residents. Of residents with a recent fracture, 9.5% used a bisphosphonate (2.7% all 3 OMs). In patients with recent falls, 20.8% used vitamin D and 15.3% calcium. In residents with severe cognitive impairment, 15.5% used vitamin D and 9.3% used calcium. Of the bisphosphonate users, 33.7% also used both vitamin D and calcium, 25.8% used only calcium in addition and 17.4% only vitamin D in addition. The use of any OM varied widely across countries, from 66.8% in Finland to 3.0% in Israel. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: We found substantial pharmacological under-treatment of prevention of osteoporosis in residents with recent falls, fractures and dependence in walking. Only two-thirds of bisphosphonate users also took a vitamin D-calcium combination, despite guideline recommendations. On the other hand, possible over-treatment was found in residents with high mortality risk in whom preventive pharmacotherapy might not have still been appropriate. The prevalence of pharmacological prevention of osteoporosis differed substantially between countries. Efforts are needed to improve pharmacotherapy in residents.

Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
Accidental FallsAgedAged, 80 and overCalcium, DietaryDiphosphonatesDrug UtilizationEuropeFemaleHumansIsraelMaleNursing HomesOsteoporosisOsteoporotic FracturesVitamin DVitamins
Study Links
Quality Scores
SafetyNot Assessed
Quality75/10
Citation Metrics
Total Citations6
Citations/Year1.5
Relative Citation Ratio0.76
NIH Percentile40.4%
Research Impact Scores
APT Score0.25
Weight Score2.29
Normalized Score0.55
Related Supplements
Pharmacological management of osteoporosis in nursing home r... | Panacea Index