Cycle ergometer training vs resistance training in ICU-acquired weakness.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to determine whether cycle ergometer training and resistance training enhance standard care for improving walking ability, lower limb strength, cardiovascular endurance, and quality of life in patients with intensive care unit-acquired weakness.
Results Summary
Ergometer and resistance training improved lower limb strength, walking ability, and cardiorespiratory fitness more effectively than standard care alone, with ergometer training potentially being superior to resistance training.
Population
Patients with severe to moderate walking disability during inpatient neurological rehabilitation for intensive care-acquired weakness.
Effective Dosage
Intervention applied 5 days a week.
Duration
4 weeks
Interactions
None mentioned
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
cycle ergometer training | increase | lower limb muscle strength | patients with severe to moderate walking disability during inpatient rehabilitation in intensive care unit acquired weakness | - | enhanced the effectiveness of standard care to improve | #1 |
cycle ergometer training | increase | walking ability | patients with severe to moderate walking disability during inpatient rehabilitation in intensive care unit acquired weakness | - | enhanced the effectiveness of standard care to improve | #2 |
cycle ergometer training | increase | cardiorespiratory fitness | patients with severe to moderate walking disability during inpatient rehabilitation in intensive care unit acquired weakness | - | enhanced the effectiveness of standard care to improve | #3 |
resistance training | increase | lower limb muscle strength | patients with severe to moderate walking disability during inpatient rehabilitation in intensive care unit acquired weakness | - | enhanced the effectiveness of standard care to improve | #4 |
resistance training | increase | walking ability | patients with severe to moderate walking disability during inpatient rehabilitation in intensive care unit acquired weakness | - | enhanced the effectiveness of standard care to improve | #5 |
resistance training | increase | cardiorespiratory fitness | patients with severe to moderate walking disability during inpatient rehabilitation in intensive care unit acquired weakness | - | enhanced the effectiveness of standard care to improve | #6 |
cycle ergometer training | neutral | - | patients with severe to moderate walking disability during inpatient rehabilitation in intensive care unit acquired weakness | - | may be superior to resistance training | #7 |
OBJECTIVES: We investigated the effectiveness of cycle ergometer training and resistance training to enhance the efficiency of standard care to improve walking ability, muscular strength of the lower limbs, cardiovascular endurance and health-related quality of life during inpatient rehabilitation in intensive care unit acquired weakness. MATERIALS & METHODS: Thirty-nine patients with severe to moderate walking disability were enrolled in one of the three experimental groups: (a) ergometer training group, (b) resistance training group and (c) control group (standard care only). Intervention was applied 5 days a week over a 4-week period during inpatient neurological rehabilitation. We evaluated walking ability (Functional Ambulation Category test, timed up and go test, 10-metre walk test and 6-minute walk test), muscle strength (Medical Research Council and maximum muscle strength tests), cardiovascular endurance and muscular endurance of the lower limbs at the fatigue threshold (physical working capacity at fatigue threshold) and quality of life (medical outcomes study SF-36 form). All tests were performed at baseline, after two weeks of treatment and at the end of the 4-week intervention period. RESULTS: Ergometer training and resistance training enhanced the effectiveness of standard care in order to improve (a) lower limb muscle strength, (b) walking ability and (c) cardiorespiratory fitness during inpatient rehabilitation of intensive care acquired weakness. In addition, ergometer training may be superior to resistance training. CONCLUSIONS: Our data encourage more research to develop and implement these training tools in rehabilitation programmes for intensive care acquired weakness.