Calf raise exercise increases walking performance in patients with intermittent claudication.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to compare the effects of calf raise exercises versus traditional walking exercises on walking performance, mitochondrial capacity, and blood flow in patients with intermittent claudication.
Results Summary
The calf raise group showed significant improvements in pain-free walking distance, maximal walking distance, claudication onset time, and peak walking time, along with increased mitochondrial volume-density, while the walking group did not show these improvements. Neither group experienced changes in maximal blood flow, peak oxygen uptake, or mitochondrial respiration.
Population
Patients with intermittent claudication (IC)
Effective Dosage
Walking group: at least 30 minutes three times a week
Duration
8 weeks
Interactions
None mentioned
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
calf raise exercise | increase | pain-free walking distance | patients with IC | 44 meters | improved | #1 |
calf raise exercise | increase | maximal walking distance | patients with IC | 99 meters | improved | #2 |
calf raise exercise | increase | claudication onset time | patients with IC | 123 seconds | increased | #3 |
calf raise exercise | increase | peak walking time | patients with IC | 104 seconds | increased | #4 |
calf raise exercise | increase | citrate synthase activity | patients with IC | - | increased | #5 |
calf raise exercise | no change | maximal blood flow | patients with IC | - | did not change | #6 |
calf raise exercise | no change | peak oxygen uptake | patients with IC | - | did not change | #7 |
calf raise exercise | no change | mitochondrial respiration | patients with IC | - | did not change | #8 |
calf raise exercise | decrease | disease anxiety | patients with IC | - | experienced less | #9 |
calf raise exercise | no change | physical activity | patients with IC | - | maintained | #10 |
traditional walking exercise | no change | pain-free walking distance | patients with IC | - | did not increase | #11 |
traditional walking exercise | no change | maximal walking distance | patients with IC | - | did not increase | #12 |
traditional walking exercise | no change | claudication onset time | patients with IC | - | did not increase | #13 |
traditional walking exercise | no change | peak walking time | patients with IC | - | did not increase | #14 |
traditional walking exercise | no change | citrate synthase activity | patients with IC | - | did not increase | #15 |
traditional walking exercise | no change | maximal blood flow | patients with IC | - | did not change | #16 |
traditional walking exercise | no change | peak oxygen uptake | patients with IC | - | did not change | #17 |
traditional walking exercise | no change | mitochondrial respiration | patients with IC | - | did not change | #18 |
traditional walking exercise | decrease | activity | patients with IC | - | reduction | #19 |
BACKGROUND: Symptoms of intermittent claudication (IC) are improved by exercise. The improvement might be secondary to increased blood perfusion or increased muscle mitochondrial capacity. Ischemia followed by reperfusion, also named preconditioning, is known to stimulate the mitochondria. We focused on a calf raise exercise inducing preconditioning in the calf muscle of patients with IC. We hypothesized that 8 weeks of this exercise would increase walking performance and mitochondrial capacity without a change in blood flow. METHODS: Patients with IC were randomized to either a calf raise exercise group (n = 14) or a traditional walking exercise group (n = 15). The calf raise group was instructed to perform a specific type of calf raise exercise three times a day. The walking group was instructed to walk near the pain threshold at least 30 minutes three times a week. Both interventions lasted 8 weeks and were not supervised. Measurements of walking performance, mitochondrial capacity, peak oxygen uptake, peripheral hemodynamics, and health-related quality of life were obtained on each patient before and after the intervention period. Adherence was measured by a training diary, and an activity monitor was used. RESULTS: The calf raise group improved pain-free walking distance by 44 meters (P = .04) and maximal walking distance by 99 meters (P = .047). Furthermore, claudication onset time increased by 123 seconds (P = .02), and peak walking time increased by 104 seconds (P = .01). The calf raise group increased the enzyme citrate synthase activity, which is a biomarker of mitochondrial volume-density in the muscle tissue (P = .02). The walking group did not increase any of these variables. Maximal blood flow, peak oxygen uptake, and mitochondrial respiration did not change in any group. The calf raise group experienced less disease anxiety (P < .01). Adherence to the instruction of exercise was 100% in the calf raise group and 80% in the walking group. The calf raise group maintained physical activity. A reduction in activity (P < .01) was found in the walking group. CONCLUSIONS: Calf raise exercise improves walking performance and increases mitochondrial volume-density in the gastrocnemius muscle without increasing blood flow in patients with IC.