Mindfulness in the Maintenance of Cognitive Capacities in Alzheimer's Disease: A Randomized Clinical Trial.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to determine whether mindfulness practice modifies the course of cognitive impairment in Alzheimer's disease (AD).
Results Summary
The mindfulness group showed significant cognitive benefits compared to the control and muscle relaxation groups, with large effect sizes over two years. Mindfulness was equivalent to cognitive stimulation therapy in maintaining cognitive function.
Population
Patients with AD (MMSE ≥18) treated with donepezil (n=120).
Effective Dosage
Three weekly sessions of mindfulness-based stimulation.
Duration
Two years.
Interactions
None mentioned.
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
mindfulness | increase | cognitive assessment CAMDEX-R (MMSE and CAMCOG) | Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation, treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 | p < 0.05 | showed significant scores compared with the control and muscle relaxation groups | #1 |
mindfulness | no change | cognitive assessment CAMDEX-R (MMSE and CAMCOG) | Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation, treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 | p≥0.05 | were equivalent | #2 |
mindfulness | increase | cognitive assessment CAMDEX-R (MMSE and CAMCOG) | Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation, treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 | p≥0.80 | had large effect size | #3 |
mindfulness | no change | cognitive function | Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation, treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 | over a period of two years | maintained cognitive function | #4 |
mindfulness | decrease | cognitive impairment | Patients with AD | - | can be used as a non-pharmacological treatment to slow cognitive impairment | #5 |
cognitive stimulation therapy | increase | cognitive assessment CAMDEX-R (MMSE and CAMCOG) | Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation, treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 | p < 0.05 | evolved better than the control group | #6 |
cognitive stimulation therapy | no change | cognitive assessment CAMDEX-R (MMSE and CAMCOG) | Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation, treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 | p≥0.05 | did not evolve better than the muscle relaxation group | #7 |
cognitive stimulation therapy | increase | cognitive assessment CAMDEX-R (MMSE and CAMCOG) | Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation, treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 | p≥0.20 | had low effect size | #8 |
progressive muscle relaxation | increase | cognitive assessment CAMDEX-R (MMSE and CAMCOG) | Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation, treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 | p≥0.50 | had moderate effect size | #9 |
BACKGROUND: The Canary Islands longitudinal study on non-pharmacological treatments showed the overall effectiveness of mindfulness in Alzheimer's disease (AD). However, no specific data on the maintenance of cognitive capacities were presented. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the practice of mindfulness modifies the course of cognitive impairment in AD. DESIGN: Longitudinal, non-inferiority and equivalence, randomized clinical trial, repeated-measures design, with three experimental groups and one control group. PARTICIPANTS: Patients with AD who voluntarily attended the Lidia García Foundation (n = 502). Only those who were treated with donepezil and MMSE ≥18 were included (n = 120). INTERVENTION: Over a two-year period, each group carried out three weekly sessions of stimulation based on mindfulness, cognitive stimulation therapy, and progressive muscle relaxation. MEASURES: Cognitive assessment CAMDEX-R (MMSE and CAMCOG). STATISTICAL ANALYSIS: Repeated-measures ANOVA (p < 0.05) and the effect size Cohen's d were performed. RESULTS: The mindfulness group showed significant scores compared with the control and muscle relaxation groups (p < 0.05), while mindfulness and cognitive stimulation therapy were equivalent (p≥0.05). Group cognitive stimulation evolved better than the control (p < 0.05) group but not better than the muscle relaxation group (p≥0.05). The effect size compared over two years was large for the mindfulness group (p≥0.80), moderate for the relaxation group (p≥0.50), and low for the cognitive stimulation group (p≥0.20). CONCLUSION: The practice of mindfulness maintained cognitive function over a period of two years. This longitudinal study suggests that mindfulness can be used as a non-pharmacological treatment to slow cognitive impairment in AD.