Is there evidence that walking groups have health benefits? A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to assess the health benefits of outdoor walking groups by analyzing physiological, psychological, and well-being outcomes.
Results Summary
The study found that walking groups significantly improved cardiovascular health (reduced blood pressure, resting heart rate), body composition (reduced body fat, BMI), cholesterol levels, and mental health (reduced depression scores). No notable adverse effects were reported.
Population
Adults participating in outdoor walking groups.
Effective Dosage
Not specified
Duration
Not specified
Interactions
None mentioned
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
outdoor walking groups | decrease | systolic blood pressure | Adults | -3.72 mm Hg | statistically significant reductions | #1 |
outdoor walking groups | decrease | diastolic blood pressure | Adults | -3.14 mm Hg | statistically significant reductions | #2 |
outdoor walking groups | decrease | resting heart rate | Adults | -2.88 bpm | statistically significant reductions | #3 |
outdoor walking groups | decrease | body fat | Adults | -1.31% | statistically significant reductions | #4 |
outdoor walking groups | decrease | body mass index | Adults | -0.71 kg/m(2) | statistically significant reductions | #5 |
outdoor walking groups | decrease | total cholesterol | Adults | -0.11 mmol/L | statistically significant reductions | #6 |
outdoor walking groups | increase | VO(2max) | Adults | 2.66 mL/kg/min | statistically significant mean increases | #7 |
outdoor walking groups | increase | SF-36 (physical functioning) score | Adults | 6.02 | statistically significant mean increases | #8 |
outdoor walking groups | increase | 6 min walk time | Adults | 79.6 m | statistically significant mean increases | #9 |
outdoor walking groups | decrease | depression scores | Adults | effect size of -0.67 | reduction | #10 |
outdoor walking groups | no change | waist circumference | Adults | - | evidence was less clear | #11 |
outdoor walking groups | no change | fasting glucose | Adults | - | evidence was less clear | #12 |
outdoor walking groups | no change | SF-36 (mental health) | Adults | - | evidence was less clear | #13 |
outdoor walking groups | no change | serum lipids such as high-density lipids | Adults | - | evidence was less clear | #14 |
outdoor walking groups | no change | adverse side effects | Adults | - | no notable adverse side effects reported | #15 |
OBJECTIVE: To assess the health benefits of outdoor walking groups. DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis of walking group interventions examining differences in commonly used physiological, psychological and well-being outcomes between baseline and intervention end. DATA SOURCES: Seven electronic databases, clinical trial registers, grey literature and reference lists in English language up to November 2013. ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: Adults, group walking outdoors with outcomes directly attributable to the walking intervention. RESULTS: Forty-two studies were identified involving 1843 participants. There is evidence that walking groups have wide-ranging health benefits. Meta-analysis showed statistically significant reductions in mean difference for systolic blood pressure -3.72 mm Hg (-5.28 to -2.17) and diastolic blood pressure -3.14 mm Hg (-4.15 to -2.13); resting heart rate -2.88 bpm (-4.13 to -1.64); body fat -1.31% (-2.10 to -0.52), body mass index -0.71 kg/m(2) (-1.19 to -0.23), total cholesterol -0.11 mmol/L (-0.22 to -0.01) and statistically significant mean increases in VO(2max) of 2.66 mL/kg/min (1.67-3.65), the SF-36 (physical functioning) score 6.02 (0.51 to 11.53) and a 6 min walk time of 79.6 m (53.37-105.84). A standardised mean difference showed a reduction in depression scores with an effect size of -0.67 (-0.97 to -0.38). The evidence was less clear for other outcomes such as waist circumference fasting glucose, SF-36 (mental health) and serum lipids such as high-density lipids. There were no notable adverse side effects reported in any of the studies. CONCLUSIONS: Walking groups are effective and safe with good adherence and wide-ranging health benefits. They could be a promising intervention as an adjunct to other healthcare or as a proactive health-promoting activity.