Panacea Index Logo

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

A review on how meditation could be used to comfort the terminally ill.

Palliative & supportive care
October 1, 2015
Michael Stephen Ball et al. (2 authors)
Journal ArticleReviewHuman Study
Study Details

Study Goal

The researchers aimed to review how meditation could comfort terminally ill patients by examining its effects on physical health, emotional health, and self-awareness.

Results Summary

The review found limited research on meditation's effects on terminally ill patients, with most studies focusing on non-terminally ill patients who reacted positively. Key areas like physical health, mental health, and self-awareness in terminally ill patients remain under-researched.

Population

Terminally ill patients (TIPs) and non-terminally ill patients (NTIPs).

Effective Dosage

Not mentioned

Duration

Not mentioned

Interactions

None mentioned

Extracted Claims (6)
InterventionDirectionEndpointPopulationDosageImpactClaim #
meditation
neutral
physical health
terminally ill patients (TIPs)
-
comforted
#1
meditation
neutral
emotional health
terminally ill patients (TIPs)
-
comforted
#2
meditation
neutral
self-awareness
terminally ill patients (TIPs)
-
comforted
#3
meditation
increase
physical health
non-terminally ill patients (NTIPs)
-
reacted positively
#4
meditation
increase
emotional health
non-terminally ill patients (NTIPs)
-
reacted positively
#5
meditation
increase
self-awareness
non-terminally ill patients (NTIPs)
-
reacted positively
#6
Abstract

OBJECTIVE: Our objective was to review how meditation could comfort the terminally ill. METHOD: Our methodology was a literature search, which included books, journals, papers in collections, and online databases. The main search engines employed were Google Scholar and the Durham University Library. The main databases consulted were the Christian Meditation Centre, Project Meditation, and Stress-Related Facts and Well-Being at Monash. We were specifically interested in data acquired from clinical and nonclinical trials. The arguments needed to be based on qualitative and quantitative scientific data. Papers were published between 1985 and 2014. We then subdivided the review into three subcategories: physical, emotional, and self-awareness. When reviewing each category, we put our results into tabular form. In each table, we noted the percentage of terminally ill patients (TIPs) and non-terminally ill patients (NTIPs), and whether meditation had comforted them. RESULTS: Our review demonstrated that there are many areas that have yet to be researched. First, very little work has been done on how meditation affects the physical health of TIPs, including such variables as blood pressure, chronic pain, and sleeping patterns. However, no research has been done on heart disease, hypertension, depression, among others. Second, virtually no research has been conducted on how meditation affects the mental health of TIPs. Notably neglected areas include anxiety, compliance, depression, and stress. Third, no research has been done on whether meditation increases self-awareness in TIPs. In each of these cases, most NTIPs reacted positively; however, no research has been done on why TIPs reacted differently. SIGNIFICANCE OF RESULTS: Our results demonstrate the need for further research on how meditation affects terminally ill patients. In turn, this would enrich the debate on whether meditation should be prescribed for the dying.

Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
AnxietyBlood PressureDatabases, BibliographicDepressionHumansMeditationPain ManagementPalliative CareSleep Wake DisordersSpiritualityTerminally Ill
Study Links
Quality Scores
SafetyNot Assessed
Efficacy30/10
Quality50/10
Citation Metrics
Total Citations4
Citations/Year0.4
Relative Citation Ratio0.25
NIH Percentile12.7%
Research Impact Scores
APT Score0.25
Weight Score1.19
Normalized Score0.42
Related Supplements